1stDibs Names Bradford Shellhammer CEO, Cuts Luxury Handbag & Watch Commissions
Former eBay VP of Buyer Experience Bradford Shellhammer is set to become CEO of luxury marketplace 1stDibs less than 18 months after joining the company, taking the top job as it looks to accelerate growth by cutting seller commissions and attracting more high-value inventory in competitive categories like handbags, watches and jewelry.
According to an announcement November 5, Shellhammer will officially become Chief Executive Officer and join the Board of Directors on January 1, 2027, succeeding David Rosenblatt, who has led the company since 2011 and will transition to Executive Chair.
Founded in 2000, 1stDibs originally focused on connecting buyers with dealers of antique and vintage furniture before expanding into a transactional marketplace offering fine art, jewelry, luxury watches, fashion and other high-end merchandise. Unlike consumer-to-consumer resale platforms, 1stDibs primarily works with professional dealers, galleries and other vetted sellers, competing for buyers looking for unique and often expensive secondhand and collectible items.
Rosenblatt credited Shellhammer with modernizing marketing and design and said he had "rebuilt our product roadmap to substantially improve the experience of our buyers and sellers" during his relatively short tenure at the company. He also told investors during the November 5 earnings call that Shellhammer has already taken responsibility for most day-to-day operations, with the promotion formalizing a leadership transition that has been underway for some time.
After spending more than six years at eBay, ultimately serving as VP of Buyer Experience, Shellhammer left in June 2022 to become Chief Product Officer at Etsy-owned musical instrument marketplace Reverb. His departure was part of a broader executive shakeup at eBay which also saw the exits of Chief Product Officer Pete Thompson, VP Buyer Experience Product and Engineering Mohan Patt and Head of Europe Rob Hattrell.
Shellhammer left Reverb in October 2024, just weeks after the company quietly eliminated more than 40 positions amid growing pressure on Etsy's House of Brands strategy. He moved to Rent the Runway later that month, but that position proved to be even shorter-lived, with 1stDibs announcing his appointment in July 2025 after less than a year.

At the time, the quick succession of moves raised questions about whether Shellhammer was choosing to leave struggling companies before their challenges became more serious. Etsy ultimately sold Reverb to Servco Pacific and Creator Partners in April 2025, while Rent the Runway continued facing financial difficulties.
His latest career move puts Shellhammer in charge of a publicly traded marketplace that has undergone its own years of restructuring, layoffs and cost-cutting as it attempts to recover from a prolonged downturn following the pandemic ecommerce boom.
According to Q3 2026 financial results released November 5, Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) increased 4% year-over-year to $92.6 million, revenue grew 5% to $23.1 million and orders rose 1%, marking the first year-over-year order growth since Q4 2024. The company also reported its fourth consecutive quarter of positive adjusted EBITDA, though it still recorded a $1.2 million GAAP net loss, compared to $3.5 million a year earlier.
Despite the improvements, active buyers declined 8% year-over-year to approximately 58,200 and unique sellers fell 3% to roughly 5,600, even as total listings surpassed 1.9 million. Management attributed much of the buyer decline to reduced marketing spending, while pointing to improving conversion rates and engagement among existing buyers. Operating expenses fell 9%, with the company's Q3 SEC filing showing a 33% reduction in sales and marketing expenses, including $2 million in lower employee-related costs largely attributed to recent reorganizations, while technology development spending increased 8%.
1stDibs has also continued returning capital to shareholders, spending $20.7 million on stock buybacks during the first nine months of 2026, bringing total repurchases since 2023 to approximately $55.7 million, with another $5 million authorized in November. Shellhammer's new CEO compensation agreement provides a $600,000 annual salary and target cash bonus of another $600,000, along with annual equity awards and a one-time promotion grant.
During the November 5 earnings call, Shellhammer explained that 1stDibs had historically applied the same commission structure across its marketplace, despite significant differences between the competitive environments and seller margins in categories like antique furniture and luxury watches.
The company began testing reduced commissions for selected luxury jewelry brands in Q2, finding that "lower commissions spurred incremental supply." Based on those results, 1stDibs expanded the program in October to include all handbags and selected luxury jewelry and watch brands, categories which together account for approximately 7% of its GMV.
The fee reductions are part of what 1stDibs calls its category acceleration strategy, combining lower commissions with business development, targeted marketing, merchandising and product improvements intended to attract more sellers and listings. Management believes the additional inventory will ultimately bring more buyers and transactions to the marketplace, offsetting at least some of the revenue lost from reducing commissions.
Lowering commissions will also affect 1stDibs' revenue in the near term, with CFO Tom Etergino telling investors that reduced take rates from the category acceleration program are expected to weigh on Q4 revenue growth. The company is forecasting GMV of $89 million to $95 million, ranging from a 1% decline to 5% growth year-over-year, while revenue is expected to range from a 3% decline to 2% growth.
The company is also making changes aimed at improving the relationship between buyers and its existing dealer network, including restoring visible seller branding on product pages and in buyer-seller messaging. Shellhammer said early testing showed the change increased checkout completion in the 1stDibs app by 8%, suggesting buyers may place additional value on knowing who they are purchasing from when shopping for high-end, often one-of-a-kind merchandise.
eBay has spent years investing in authentication infrastructure and category-specific experiences to attract buyers and sellers of high-value merchandise, including moving some luxury watch authentication in-house last year and expanding optional paid authentication for lower-priced luxury handbags.
The company also brought former executive Renee Paradise back in August to oversee its global fashion business, which generates more than $10 billion in annual GMV, with luxury and pre-owned merchandise among its biggest growth drivers. Meanwhile, former eBay Global Fashion VP Alexis Hoopes joined luxury resale rival The RealReal as Chief Merchandising Officer in October, bringing experience developing eBay's luxury inventory and partnerships.
In August, Poshmark acquired the operational facilities of Linda's Stuff, the longtime eBay seller that had served as the company's exclusive US luxury consignment partner, handling everything from receiving and authenticating merchandise to photographing, pricing, listing and fulfillment. Linda's Stuff also moved its selling and livestream shopping operations exclusively to Poshmark.
Poshmark plans to use the acquired facilities to build a centralized luxury consignment service, replacing its previous community-powered approach with physical infrastructure for authentication, inventory handling and fulfillment. The loss of Linda's Stuff also leaves questions about eBay's own US luxury consignment offering, which has disappeared from the company's website without any public explanation about whether another partner will take over.
1stDibs also restricts how dealers can price merchandise across multiple sales channels. According to its 2025 annual report, sellers are required to maintain price parity, meaning items listed on 1stDibs must be priced at or below what the same seller advertises elsewhere. The company also offers a Price-Match Guarantee to eligible buyers who find the same item advertised for less on another platform, limiting dealers' ability to offer lower prices through channels with lower selling costs.
Asked whether 1stDibs might expand commission reductions beyond the handbag, watch and jewelry categories that currently account for approximately 7% of GMV, Shellhammer said research with existing dealers had uncovered "untapped inventory" they weren't listing because the commissions were not economically attractive. He pointed to opportunities in furniture, art and other categories, including bedroom furniture, but said the company had not yet decided whether to extend the lower fees.
